Pope Pius XI: an Assassination at the Vatican?
Posted: Tuesday, November 03, 2009
by Carolyn Tytler
A sudden, unexpected death is shocking, especially when the victim is well-known, young, and apparently healthy. Some find it hard to believe that, in the normal course of events, a person can be here one day and gone the next. When President John F. Kennedy, Marilyn Monroe and Princess Diana passed away, it wasn't long before conspiracy theories began to appear.
Ambrogio Damiano Achille Ratti was born near Milan, Italy in 1857. He was ordained a priest in 1879. A brilliant scholar, he worked in the Vatican library, becoming its head in 1914. It was at this time he came to the attention of Pope Benedict XV.
In 1919, Father Ratti became a cardinal and he was sent to Warsaw, Poland, as Papal Nuncio. There, he developed effective diplomatic skills. He returned to Italy in 1921 and became cardinal archbishop of Milan. In 1922, as Benito Mussolini marched toward Rome, Achille Ratti was elected Pope. He chose the name Pius XI.
During his pontificate, he negotiated the Lateran Treaty with Italy , through which the Vatican became a fully sovereign state. He successfully negotiated peaceful relations between Church and state in Mexico. He signed a concordat with Germany, which that country quickly violated. He increased the number of diplomatic missions around the world.
In the closing months of his reign, he became more closely associated with democracies in the West, realizing that they were all threatened by the militant regimes of Hitler, Mussolini and the Soviet Union.
Pius XI spoke out against all forms of racism, anti- Semitism, nationalism and totalitarianism, under which one leader or one party holds complete control of a government. He promoted human dignity for all people. He believed in the brotherhood of man under the Fatherhood of God.
On November 25, 1938, the Pope suffered two heart attacks within several hours. Following these he had breathing problems. In February, 1939, his condition deteriorated. He had pain and difficulty walking. Soon, he was unable to leave his bed because of serious breathing problems.
He was extremely ill, and his team of doctors announced to Vatican staff that his prognosis was poor. He died at age 81, of a third heart attack at 5:31 A.M. (Rome Time) on February 10, 1939, shortly before World War II broke out.
Supposedly, before his death, he was writing an encyclical condemning all forms of totalitarianism, including Nazism and Fascism. His successor, Pope Pius XII chose not to deliver it exactly as it had been written, since hostilities were already at a peak and, in fact, World W ar II had begun.
Soon, talk of assassination surfaced. The Pope's chief doctor was Francesco Petracci, the father of Claretta Petracci, who was Mussolini's mistress. The doctor possibly had motive and opportunity to inject the already frail pontiff with a lethal dose of some drug, causing immediate death.
Had Pope Pius lived to deliver his encyclical, popular support for the enemy powers would have been weakened just as the Nazis and their allies were launching aggressive invasions. Enemy commanders needed complete dedication and high moral among their troops to subdue the citizens of invaded countries.
Despite the distinct possibility that Pope Pius XI was assassinated, I would argue that it was unlikely, for these reasons:
* A team of doctors had already declared that the Pope, 81 years old, to be gravely ill.
* It was doubtful that he had the strength to finish writing the encyclical,, let alone deliver it.
* Had his death been in any way unusual or unexpected, one of the other physicians would have spoken up.
* Doctor Petracci would only have had to wait a short time and the Pope would have died of natural causes, sparing him the danger of being discovered and prosecuted.
President Kennedy, Marilyn Monroe and Princess Diana were young, vigorous people when they died suddenly and unexpectedly. Had they lived their normal life span, they might have caused serious problems or become major obstacles for other people, some of whom may have been completely unscrupulous.
In contrast, Pope Pius XI was a frail, sick, old man already at the point of death. Would any doctor be foolish enough to risk his freedom and reputation to kill a Pope, even to accomodate his daughter's love interest? I sincerely doubt it.
On this occasion, at least, it seems unlikely that an assassination was carried out in the papal apartments within the walls of the Vatican.
This Article has been viewed 877 times. (Not updated in real-time.)
Top-level comments on this article: (3 total)That's exact that Pius XI was very ill and it was only a question of time when he would die of natural causes. Perhaps he really died of natural causes.But it remains "strange" that he died exactly the day before the 10th anniversary of the "Lateran treaty" (11th february) between Italy and the Holy See. Pius XI had prepared a speech for this day in which he would condemn fascism, nazism and antisemitism. In addition, for the subsequent day, 12th February, it was planned that he would have personal talks with the Bishops assembled in Rome for the event, to hear directly their personal opinions on the actual situation, and I think this was estimated by certain "inner curial" circles at least as "dangerous" as his speech.Many high prelates in the Roman curia, Pacelli (Pius XII) comprised, did all they could to prevent Pius XI from speeking out against nazism and the persecution of the Jews. So why - if an assassination is not excluded - the suspect is put only on Petacci resp. Mussolini?Are prelates above any suspicion?
You have a point, Anonymous. Every barrel of apples may contain one or even several rotten ones. I'd like to think that this particular barrel would contain fewer than the usual, but you never know. Thank you for reading and commenting.
The author Malachi Martin has written just the opposite. He states succinctly that Pius XI was murdered as was JPI. He was a Vatican insider who walked away to write of the corruption in the Vatican.
We want your comments! If you can read this, you don't have javascript enabled, so you can't use this comment system. Please enable javascript.